How To Make Beef Broth

Beef broth is a little different from vegetable broth or chicken broth. Vegetable broth is made from vegetable ends you collect and boil, while chicken broth is made from the leftover bones of a chicken after you have used all the meat. As such, both are uber frugal and useful staples in the kitchen.
Beef broth, however, uses the knucklebones of a cow. These things:

Butchers used to sell knucklebones for next to nothing, making beef broth frugal as well, but these days around here, knucklebones can go for as high as $3 a pound and are rarely under $2 a pound. Since you need 5 pounds of knuckleboness to make 10 cups of broth, this isn’t as high a savings as say, the completely free cost of making vegetable broth. But if you buy the knucklebones on sale, it’s still cheaper than paying for beef broth by the can.
And there’s another reason to make your own beef broth: quality. Homemade beef broth tastes about a zillion times better than the packaged stuff, and gives anything you put it in–soup, stews, etc.–a sense of umami that it wouldn’t otherwise have.
Since I was craving French onion soup, I decided to make the broth by hand. The only thing I purchased for the broth was the knucklebones. Many recipes tell you to use whole vegetables in your beef broth, but since that adds to the cost of the broth, I use vegetable ends that normally would be tossed in the compost. As I’m cooking, I collect these ends in a freezer bag until time to use in broth. When I am ready to cook the broth, I dump the frozen vegetables in the pan with the rest of the ingredients. Other than that, I added water, a bay leaf, and salt to the broth.
You’ll notice that my broth isn’t as dark a brown as the beef broth you’re used to seeing. This is because most beef broth in the store is colored. By itself, beef broth is only a little darker than chicken broth. There are ways to color the broth yourself, but since it adds nothing to the taste, I don’t see the point in bothering.
Here’s the recipe:

Beef Broth

(Makes 10-12 cups)

    5 lbs beef knucklebones
    Onion ends (the equivalent of about 1-2 small onion)
    Carrot peelings and ends
    Parsley stems (a small handful)
    The tops of celery
    5 or 6 garlic slivers
    1 bay leaf
    ~ 2 Tbs salt
    Enough water to cover, about 14 cups


Turn the oven to 425 degrees. Put the beef knuckles in a pan and roast for 30 minutes until brown:

The bones will have released a lot of fat, which you should drain from the pan without discarding any carmelized cooking bits. Add the knucklebones and the brown flavor bits to a soup pan. Add the vegetable ends, bay leaf, and water.
Bring to a boil then reduce to a simmer. Cook for about three hours or until the beef broth is golden brown and flavorful.
Taste the broth. Add about half the salt, taste. Add remaining salt. (I do it this way to avoid over salting.)
Strain out the bones and vegetables, then transfer the broth to the fridge overnight. A disc of fat will form on the top of the broth. Remove the fat and discard.
Put the remaining broth to containers and freeze until needed. Enjoy!

Sharing is caring!

4 thoughts on “How To Make Beef Broth”

  1. I am SO EXCITED that you posted this. I’m a locavore and I’ve been making my own broth recently. I keep seeing beef soup bones at the farm where I often buy meat, but really wasn’t quite sure what to do with it and whether it was worth the effort. But I do use beef broth often, for that uh – umami thing it’s got going on. I use double-strength. Maybe with homemade, I won’t have to double-strength everything. Well heck, even if I do, I’ll just do it in a crockpot overnight.
    I’m also extremely grateful to you for explaining that the store stuff has coloring in it. I’d have been wondering what on earth I’d done wrong!
    That same farm just had a crazy sale on soup chickens – laying hens that were past their prime. I cooked three of them together in a big old canning pot; because they were layers they genuinely took hours and hours and hours to cook, but the broth was SO good (once you skimmed off the massive amounts of fat – measuring cups full!) and meat still had a lot of flavor even after all that boiling! If you can get your hands on some layers for cheap, it’s totes worth it. They were selling these for $4.50 each, and local chickens are usually at least $3 a pound.

  2. I have a question, can u just use the juices from, say a roast? Like
    you would to make gravy. And if you can’t whats the difference?

  3. Lillian, Thanks for the nice comment! I’m glad the post was helpful to you.
    Janelle, while you can use the juices from a roast as flavoring in a dish, beef broth is made from bones. It has bone marrow in it, while gravy is made from fat/meat tissue.

  4. Pingback: Savvy Housekeeping » 5 Household Skills That Save Money

Leave a Comment